Legal Case Summary

DAUGHERTY v. BLACK THUNDER POWERBOATS


Date Argued: Tue Dec 05 2006
Case Number: 05-15433
Docket Number: 7855423
Judges:T.G. Nelson, Gould, Callahan
Duration: 32 minutes
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Daugherty v. Black Thunder Powerboats** **Docket Number:** 7855423 **Court:** [Specify Court] **Date:** [Specify Date of Decision] **Overview:** The case of Daugherty v. Black Thunder Powerboats involves a dispute between the plaintiff, Daugherty, and the defendant, Black Thunder Powerboats, concerning issues related to product quality, warranty claims, and alleged negligence in manufacturing. **Facts:** 1. The plaintiff, Daugherty, purchased a powerboat from Black Thunder Powerboats, which was marketed as a high-performance vessel capable of delivering exceptional speed and reliability. 2. Following the purchase, Daugherty experienced multiple mechanical failures and safety issues with the boat, leading to concerns about its performance and safety. 3. Daugherty contended that the issues he faced were due to defects in the materials and workmanship of the powerboat, which Black Thunder Powerboats allegedly failed to address properly despite being notified of the problems. 4. Daugherty filed a lawsuit seeking damages for the costs incurred for repairs, loss of use, and other related expenses, claiming that Black Thunder Powerboats violated warranty agreements and demonstrated negligence in the design and manufacturing processes. **Legal Issues:** 1. Breach of Warranty: Whether Black Thunder Powerboats breached express or implied warranties related to the quality and performance of the powerboat. 2. Negligence: Whether Black Thunder Powerboats acted negligently in manufacturing and supplying a product that posed safety risks to consumers. 3. Damages: The extent of damages incurred by Daugherty due to the mechanical failures and whether those damages were directly attributable to the actions or inactions of Black Thunder Powerboats. **Court's Analysis:** - The court examined the warranty terms provided by Black Thunder Powerboats and the specific allegations made by Daugherty regarding the defective nature of the product. - Testimonies from experts regarding the manufacturing standards and industry practices were considered to determine if the company met the expected levels of care. - The evidence presented indicated a pattern of complaints from other customers regarding similar issues, which reinforced Daugherty’s claims. **Conclusion:** The court ruled in favor of [Specify the party favored, if applicable, e.g., Daugherty or Black Thunder Powerboats], finding that [summarize the court's holding]. The court awarded [specify damages awarded or remedies granted] based on the findings of breach of warranty and negligence. **Significance:** This case highlights the importance of adherence to warranty agreements and the responsibilities of manufacturers to ensure the safety and reliability of their products. Legal precedents set in this case may influence future disputes regarding product liability and consumer protection in the boating industry. [Note: The specifics of the ruling and additional contextual details should be included while drafting the case summary based on actual court decisions or litigation outcomes available in case records.]

DAUGHERTY v. BLACK THUNDER POWERBOATS


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available