Legal Case Summary

Rochelle Garza, as guardian ad liten to unaccompanied minor J.D., on behalf of herself and others similarly situated v. Eric D. Hargan, Acting Secretary, Health and Human Services


Date Argued: Fri Oct 20 2017
Case Number: 17-5236
Docket Number: 6173206
Judges:Henderson, Kavnaugh, Millett
Duration: 92 minutes
Court Name: D.C Circuit

Case Summary

**Case Summary: Rochelle Garza, as Guardian ad Litem to Unaccompanied Minor J.D., on Behalf of Herself and Others Similarly Situated v. Eric D. Hargan, Acting Secretary of Health and Human Services (Docket No. 6173206)** **Court:** United States District Court **Date Filed:** [Please insert filing date] ### Background: This case involves Rochelle Garza, who serves as a guardian ad litem for an unaccompanied minor, referred to as J.D. The case was brought against Eric D. Hargan, the Acting Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS). The plaintiffs, represented by Garza, argue on behalf of other unaccompanied minors similarly situated to J.D. ### Facts: The case centers on the treatment and rights of unaccompanied minors in the custody of federal authorities. Specifically, it addresses issues regarding the legal representation, welfare, and appropriate care of these minors while they are detained. The plaintiffs assert that HHS has failed in its duty to provide adequate protections and services to unaccompanied minors, violating their rights and the applicable laws governing their treatment. ### Claims: The claims in this case include allegations that the policies and practices employed by HHS do not comply with the legal standards set forth in the applicable statutes and regulations concerning the treatment of unaccompanied minors. The plaintiffs may argue that the minors are entitled to due process rights and that HHS's actions have caused harm to their physical and mental well-being. ### Legal Issues: The case raises significant legal questions regarding the responsibilities of HHS concerning unaccompanied minors, including: 1. The adequacy of legal representation provided to these minors. 2. The conditions of detention and care for unaccompanied minors. 3. The compliance of HHS policies with federal law and international obligations to protect child welfare. ### Relief Sought: The plaintiffs are seeking declaratory and injunctive relief, which may include orders mandating reforms in HHS's treatment of unaccompanied minors, improved access to legal representation, and enhanced protections for their rights during the immigration process. ### Conclusion: This case highlights critical issues surrounding the treatment of vulnerable populations within the immigration system, particularly unaccompanied minors. The outcome could have significant implications for how HHS manages the care and legal rights of these children, setting a precedent for future policies and practices affecting unaccompanied minors in the United States. (Note: Specific details such as dates, court levels, and additional procedural history should be updated as appropriate for accuracy.)

Rochelle Garza, as guardian ad liten to unaccompanied minor J.D., on behalf of herself and others similarly situated v. Eric D. Hargan, Acting Secretary, Health and Human Services


Oral Audio Transcript(Beta version)

no audio transcript available